Of topoi and memes
Diplo Wisdom Circle, Revisit Social media BlogsThe text discusses the controversial figure Richard Dawkins, criticizing his once-popular theories like the "selfish gene" concept and the idea of memes. It delves into the historical origins of memes, known as topoi in Greek antiquity, and their role in shaping discourse. The text also touches on the maxim "know thyself," tracing its influence through various philosophical traditions. It concludes by highlighting the purpose of topoi in combining authority with change, emphasizing the importance of meditation in philosophical thought.
The abuse of analogies: Upon reading the article ‘Reading the CCP Clearly’
Diplo Wisdom Circle, Revisit Diplomatic theory and practice BlogsThe article 'Reading the CCP Clearly' discusses the inappropriate use of analogies in foreign policy decision-making, specifically referencing historical analogies related to Hitler and Mao. It explores China's unique economic and political development, emphasizing the dangers of oversimplified comparisons in international relations. The author warns against relying on outdated slogans and analogies and highlights the complexity of China's culture and history.
A tale of influencers
Diplo Wisdom Circle, Revisit Politics and governance BlogsInfluencers throughout history, from priests to modern-day marketers, have shaped societal beliefs through verbal, visual, and written communication. The messages conveyed by influencers, such as the 'American Dream' and 'America First', have evolved over time, reflecting changes in societal values and political climates. The 'American Dream' shifted from collective welfare to individual prosperity, while 'America First' has represented ethno-nationalism and systemic racism. Understanding the complex interplay between messages, meanings, and socioeconomic contexts is crucial to unraveling the impact of influencers on society and politics.
Third-party counterinsurgency: Evolution and challenges
RevisitHow has third-party counterinsurgency evolved over time, and what challenges persist? Aldo Matteucci examines the complexities.
What are vanity and interstitial states?
RevisitThe message explores the concepts of "vanity" and "interstitial" states, highlighting historical instances of arbitrary border changes and the complexities of border integrity. It discusses the origins of these terms and their impact on international relations, emphasizing the need to recognize and respect the complexity of historically formed borders for peaceful resolutions. Efforts to mitigate conflicts related to borders are essential, with a suggestion to consider letting interstitial states exist without interference as a potential way forward in resolving territorial disputes.
Analogies and metaphors as mental maps
RevisitAnalogies and metaphors help us grasp complex ideas like climate change, but they can also distort truth if unchecked. How do we balance the ease of familiar metaphors with the need for accurate understanding?
Uses and abuses of conspiracy theory
Revisit BlogsThe text discusses the use of conspiracy theories in political analysis, emphasizing the importance of focusing on plausible explanations rather than striving for absolute truth. It suggests that in complex social systems, understanding implications of events is more crucial than determining the true cause. The text critiques the pursuit of original intent or "plausible truth," advocating for a middle ground that considers all factors without insisting on definitive causation. It also contrasts the modern emphasis on individual agency with the more broad social forces recognized in old Marxism.
Wisdom is what’s lost in translation – or – A story from the land of false friends
RevisitThe text discusses the loss of wisdom in translation, emphasizing the importance of cultural contexts and the danger of misinterpretation. Western and Asian perspectives, particularly regarding the concept of "balance," are compared, highlighting cultural nuances. Examples are provided, such as misunderstandings in historical events and literary translations. The text calls for a deeper understanding of foreign cultures rather than mere translation, suggesting that direct translation may lead to a loss of meaning. The importance of preserving cultural contexts and avoiding appropriation through translation is emphasized.
Copycat China
RevisitThe text discusses the intricate societal dynamics in China, delving into its history, cultural revolutions, and current economic frenzy. It highlights the prevalence of a "copycat" phenomenon and the impact on social morality. The narrative questions the Communist Party's role in addressing corruption and the need for political reforms. An author's reflection on personal deceit serves as a metaphor for broader societal complexities. The text concludes with a poetic excerpt, emphasizing the silence as a virtue.
Notes from the barren shoals of international relations ‘theory’
RevisitThe text discusses the flaws in current international relations theories, including the concept of "offensive realism" and its implications on great power dynamics, particularly between China and the United States. It points out contradictions and dangers in such theories, suggesting a need for a pragmatic approach towards a potential conflict. The author questions the predictability of such theories and highlights the importance of avoiding self-fulfilling prophecies.
