What is “best practice?”
DeepDip 2The author critiques the term "best practice," deeming it an oxymoron as adaptation determines effectiveness. They share a video displaying the dynamic relationship between a drongo bird and meerkats in Africa, suggesting using it to illustrate teaching "best practice.
Three outstanding US diplomats
DeepDip 2The text highlights the importance of internal dissent within diplomatic circles, citing examples of diplomats like Archer, Robert White, and H. Carl Gettinger who stood up against government demands, even at the expense of their careers. These diplomats demonstrated the value of principled dissent in diplomacy, urging readers to learn from their stories.
The US Presidential elections: A preview from the past
DeepDip 2The preview discusses a manga on Japan's history and links it to the upcoming US Presidential election. It highlights how conviction can overpower facts in decision-making and how following the loudest voice may seem safer. The message emphasizes the importance of facts and prudence in decision-making, cautioning against blindly following popular opinions.
Are states ‘rational actors’?
DeepDip 2The text discusses the concept of states as rational actors in international relations, emphasizing the importance of learning from past mistakes rather than assuming infallibility. It provides historical examples, such as the Seven Deadly Sins of the German Reich, to illustrate the consequences of irrational decisions made by states. The text warns against blindly accepting the assumption that states act in a rational manner, as this can lead to dangerous outcomes.
India’s foreign policy as “crooked timber”
DeepDip 2India's foreign policy is seen as “crooked timber” due to its lack of clear overarching objectives and historical complexities. Ambassador Kishan S. Rana advocates for a more articulate and transparent foreign policy, departing from India's traditional "strategic autonomy." India's geopolitical ambiguity, historical multiculturalism, and the intertwining of domestic and foreign policies further complicate its stance. Rana suggests that India's adaptive approach, akin to a meandering river, is more suited to its unique circumstances rather than setting rigid goals. This adaptive stance reflects India's historical complexities and challenges in dealing with a diverse geopolitical landscape.
Should NGOs be involved in foreign policy formulation?
DeepDip 2NGOs, historically influential in foreign affairs, have morphed from trade-related entities to advocates for regime change, human rights, and democratization. Diasporas can impact policies, while groups like Masonic Lodges have funded historical events. NGOs have impacted foreign policy, advocating for interventions and institutional development. The role of NGOs in foreign policy formulation is important but must be carefully balanced with traditional diplomatic processes to prevent undue influence based on conviction rather than experience. The message highlights the potential risks of allowing individual interests to dictate foreign policy decisions.
NATO’s puzzling bafflement: The Mystery of ISIS (book)
DeepDip 2NATO’s puzzling bafflement is explored in the article "The Mystery of ISIS," dwelling on the group’s unconventional tactics and the significance of territory. The author questions why NATO fails to understand ISIS's strategies, emphasizing the importance of territory for revolutionary movements. The text reflects on historical insurgencies, highlighting the paradox of holding ground in guerrilla warfare. It discusses ISIS's choice of Mosul as a sanctuary, linking it to territorial sovereignty and the symbolism of reclaiming dignity. The article's arguments underscore the complexity of grasping ISIS's motivations and methods amid ongoing conflict.
Khiva: A dashing humanitarian mission
DeepDip 2In Khiva, Lieutenant Richmond Shakespear undertook a daring humanitarian mission in the 19th century, convincing the Khan to release Russian prisoners and abolishing ownership of Russian slaves. He led a group of captives to safety and later rescued British prisoners in Kabul. Knighted for his actions, he prevented Russians from taking over Khiva. This heroic effort showcased his compassion and diplomacy in challenging circumstances.
Do we have a moral obligation to save wild bees?
DeepDip 2The author reflects on the moral obligation to save wild bees as essential for ecosystem biodiversity and ponders the conflict between moral and economic arguments. With 80% of crop pollination dependent on just 2% of wild bee species, the decline of these vital pollinators raises concerns. The imperative to preserve biodiversity carries economic costs and raises questions about burden-sharing and practical strategies. While acknowledging challenges and complexities in dealing with biodiversity conservation, the author stresses the need to weigh consequences and costs in pursuing this crucial goal.
Rights of future generations: The emptiness and the plenitude
DeepDip 2The text discusses the evolution and challenges of intergenerational rights, emphasizing the theoretical emptiness in resolving conflicts between generations. It questions the feasibility of achieving distributive justice and the paternalistic nature of projecting current realities onto the future. Countries like New Zealand and Hungary are highlighted for their practical approach in managing environmental issues through inclusive institutions as a solution. The text suggests that focusing on practical actions and inclusiveness rather than theoretical debates may be more effective in securing the rights of future generations.